Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Wisconsin Cheese Curds
Reuben Rolls
Chicken Wrap
Chicken Cordon Bleu
About
In Cahoots & Co
Welcome to In Cahoots & Co, a delightful gem nestled in Genesee Depot, Wisconsin. Located at S43W31325 WI-83, this charming bar and eatery has made quite the name for itself in the local dining scene, especially among those who appreciate a cozy atmosphere and a hearty meal.
As a food reviewer for Foodjoyy, I am particularly struck by In Cahoots & Co’s dedication to classic pub fare. If you find yourself wandering through Wisconsin, you must indulge in their renowned Wisconsin Cheese Curds for a perfect appetizer. Customers rave about their fish fry, which has been hailed as the best in the Great Lakes region. With a perfect light breading that makes the fish just flaky enough, it’s no surprise that diners like James Nestler have made the trek for this remarkable dish—just be sure to arrive early, as these delicacies are known to disappear quickly!
Among their broad selection, the Chicken Cordon Bleu sandwich and the classic Reuben/Rachel both stand out on the menu, each priced reasonably under $10.25. For those craving a traditional bite, the Classic BLT remains a timeless favorite. Additionally, their dinner baskets, including the crispy shrimp basket with fries, ensure that both casual diners and families leave happy and satisfied.
The experience at In Cahoots & Co is about more than just the food; it’s the atmosphere that truly encapsulates the small-town charm of Wisconsin. A local haven, Tom Smith describes it as the perfect place for a drink or quick bite, featuring a collection of intriguing photographs that add character to its welcoming vibe. Here, you can enjoy your meal without the overwhelming noise that often accompanies busy restaurants. It’s an environment where conversations thrive, and friends gather, solidifying its status as a community favorite.
If you’re in the area, don’t miss out on what In Cahoots & Co has to offer. As one customer pointed out, bringing a big city attitude may not do justice to this cozy pub—embracing the local charm and enjoying the classic and creative culinary options is certainly the way to go. With friendly service and a menu packed with delightful choices, your visit will surely be memorable.
So why wait? Grab your friends, head to In Cahoots & Co, and experience a slice of Wisconsin's rich dining culture! You won't be disappointed.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Who would have thought that a tiny bar buried in Wisconsin would have the absolutely best baked fish offering in the Great Lakes region? Get there early though because these amazing dishes sell out fast! Staff is amazing as well! ”
“ Best fish fry I have had to date!! The patio and service left something to be desired, but it all faded away once we got our fish. Perfect light breading, moist and flakey. The homemade potato pancakes topped off the meal. We will be back! ”
“ Very good fish fry and reasonably priced drinks. Also, excellent service!! ”
“ Amazing local small town pub with a welcoming vibe. Encourage all to stop for a beverage. Classic menu with interesting options and specials posted at the bar. Limited kitchen is very efficient yet stressed by unexpected large groups with ‘big city’ attitude. Enjoy the difference. ”
“ In Cahoots is my go to local bar, whenever I feel like going out for a quick drink or bite to eat this is my choice. The atmosphere is very welcoming and the staff is very friendly. The photos they have on the walls are all very interesting, I especially like the old style wanted posters. I definitely recommend this establishment if you want a down to earth environment where you can actually hear your companies conversation without yelling at each other to be heard. ”
“ Very good fish fry, fresh bread, tasty curly fries very good tarter sauce. Fish cooked just right. Our server was friendly and good. Bonus, they had a rubber duck claw machine! ”
“ Service and food is 5 stars x 2 10 stars! 4 stars for Atmosphere because it is noisy due to its popularity having a packed house! : ) Waitresses and bar tenders super friendly. Nice tap beers, I like the Riverwest lager. There is free street parking, but if no spaces, there is free parking a short distance away at the Town Hall. ”
“ Great food! Friendly staff! Nice atmosphere with outdoor seating. Olivia, our bartender/server, was great! Highly recommend their fish fry. Great cod, my husband loved the walleye. Only 12.99 for three huge pieces of cod with fries or potato pancakes, bread, coleslaw, tarter and bread. Best place I've had a fish fry in a while. ”